With the Attack on Titan manga doing extremely well and Season 2 of the anime on the horizon, I finally decided to watch the OVA’s as an extra way to immerse myself into the universe again. It was also the perfect excuse to get back to watching OVA’s as I said I would do months ago (see! Told you I’d get back to it…eventually), so as promised, here’s another round of OVA minireviews – the Attack on Titan edition!
Ilse’s Notebook: Memoirs of a Recon Corps Member
Based on an early side chapter from the Attack on Titan manga, “Ilse’s Notebook” explores the story of a Scouting Legion member after she is separated from her squad. The OVA does a good job of expanding on her journey of survival, showing her traversing the land and writing in her notebook, in addition to showing Levi and Hanji during their mission before they find her remains. Ilse’s interactions with the speaking Titan are largely the same as in the manga, but her death is a bit over the top. In the OVA, she continues narrating her experiences in her notebook, even as she is inside the Titan’s mouth, before dying. I have no doubt the scene was trying to be powerful, but for me it just came off as silly. Interestingly, at the end of the OVA Levi and Hanji find her body placed inside of a tree, almost as a sign of worship or reverence from the Titan that killed her. This had really interesting implications considering that all they found of her in the manga was her notebook.
No Regrets: Parts 1 and 2
“No Regrets: Parts 1 and 2” are based on the spin-off manga series written a few years ago. I wrote an extensive review about this manga before and the issues I had with it, and unfortunately, the OVA’s don’t fare much better. They’re gorgeously animated, as is expected from Studio Wit, but the characters and plot suffer much of the same issues as the manga did. The fact that his friends are killed off screen is also an issue because of the impact they were meant to have on him, as was explored more in Part 1. The scene when Levi goes berserk and kills the Titans is very animalistic-looking, but the fact that he kills much fewer than in the spin-off manga makes it painfully difficult to believe his ascension to becoming the best soldier in the Scouting Legion just a year later. These OVA’s aren’t much better than the manga they’re retelling, but the animation is certainly worth it and manages to make the friendship a little more convincing.
“Distress” features an original story of the 104th prior to their graduation. They’re assigned to work in teams, but as expected, Eren and Jean don’t get along, and this makes things difficult for their leader, Marco. There’s a surprising amount of character development for Marco, and this is rather nice considering his limited role in the anime. Things go awry when Krista is kidnapped by bandits, and they must all work together to save her, leading to a pretty cleverly done rescue mission. Overall, I think this OVA was decent. It gives character development where it’s least expected and manages to have clever moments as well.
The Sudden Visitor: The Torturous Curse of Youth This OVA is based on the ending panels Isayama likes to close out the manga volumes with. These are often very comedic and completely random, such as Jean hiding from his mother or Sasha holding a cooking contest (among others). “The Sudden Visitor” combines many of these random scenes by merging them into an amusing but heartwarming narrative. Jean is rather distant with his mother, and after getting into a scuffle with Sasha, is challenged to a cooking contest. They compete to hunt a large boar for the contest, and after Sasha kills it and claims it for her team, Jean reflects on his past with his mother and the food she made him. He presents a homemade omelette at the contest and is declared the winner because of the love he put into the dish. This OVA is definitely the most comedic and lighthearted of the four, but it’s still very well done because it still handles the emotions in a mature way.
The Attack on Titan OVA’s are overall good, and I hope that the OVA’s for Season 2 will be even better. Season 2 should cover a lot of amazing content for the OVA’s to reference and work from.
Gurren Lagann is among my favorite anime shows ever with its engaging story, great cast of characters and epic soundtrack. A couple of years after the show came out, Gurren Lagann was retold in two movies: Childhood’s End and The Lights in the Sky are Stars. I had always been interested in watching the movies to see what changes were made, but sadly the movies weren’t dubbed or released in the states. I finally took the plunge and watched them online to see how they hold up in comparison to the show. Are the films good adaptations of the show, and are they worth watching? Let’s find out!
Warning: if you haven’t seen Gurren Lagann, there will be spoilers ahead! Read at your own risk!
The beginning of Childhood’s End depicts Lordgenome’s childhood and his battle with the AntiSpirals, using footage from Parallel Works 8. I talked about the significance of Parallel Works 8 before, and this scene functions as intended, providing a strong back story to the plot while introducing relevant characters and ideas. This was a great way introduction that is substantially different from how the show started, and arguably better for it too. If only the rest Childhood’s End went as smoothly.
In Gurren Lagann, the time skip is instantaneous and doesn’t waste any time developing the story even further. In the beginning The Lights in the Sky are Stars (after the poorly placed Lordgenome fight at the start, which I’ll talk about later), the time skip is supplemented with a montage of major events that take place over the course of the seven years. By showing the progression of civilization through the time skip, it helps develop the world and provide a real sense of change. It also does a good job of showing the characters mature and change during this time so that it’s not as stark of a transformation.
Not only are many of the characters fleshed out, but so are their relationships with each other. Simon and Nia’s relationship in Gurren Lagann is already fantastic as it is, and the fact that The Lights in the Sky are Stars manages to expand on this in a meaningful way is great. Not only that, but their relationship is even cuter! The few scenes added between them helps add investment into their story and make the audience root for Nia’s rescue even more.
Simon’s time in prison in Gurren Lagann was pretty short, and The Lights in the Sky expands on this a bit. Simon gets some great character development that hasn’t been seen before in the show through these added scenes, and he goes to a pretty dark place. It also gives viewers a clue of just how powerful he has become and trying to control this power by refusing to fight the other inmates. It shows a more natural progression for Simon giving up and thereby accepting the reality of the situation – in the show this was a rather quick turn that came out of nowhere, and the movie allows us to see this change more slowly and understand his actions.
The final battle in The Lights in the Sky are Stars is even more bombastic and insane than in the show. A lot of the craziness was overwhelming even as a fan of the over the top action, but the main thing I thought this sequence did very well was the individual fights against the AntiSpiral. Characters like Yoko, Viral, and Nia get their own mecha to fight with, and Nia’s contribution to the battle is the best (despite the overemphasis on her nudity). Not only does she get to fight back (the first time she’s been given a chance to do so), but she also draws first blood against the AntiSpiral while protecting Simon. The fact that Nia is able to protect him for a change is a notable moment for her considering her brainwashed and kidnapped status from before. Her mecha also has the best design and is a perfect fit for her character.
In Gurren Lagann, the long, hard fought battle against the AntiSpirals concludes with Simon killing the AntiSpiral leader with Lagann. In The Lights in the Sky are Stars, Lagann is incapacitated and forces Simon to fight the AntiSpiral one on one. The animation is rough and gritty, reflecting the intensity of this fist fight. I think this scene of the two fist fighting is great because it’s forcing them to rely on their own strength and will to win rather than mecha. It adds a new layer to the strength of humanity that was already so emphasized in the show, and makes it even more prominent in the movie’s conclusion.
As many changes as The Lights in the Sky are Stars makes, the ending is still bittersweet. It does add some nice scenes of Nia writing in her diary for the last time while Simon prepares to pass Lagann down to the next generation before the wedding. Their marriage itself largely plays out the same, but makes a very subtle change that greatly affects the scene that follows, which I’ll talk about next.
Originally, after Nia disappears, Gimmy desperately asks why Simon can’t just resurrect her. In the anime, Simon’s response is a grin as he says that he’s accepted her fate. In the movie, Simon’s grin remains but now his eyebrows are furrowed. This is a very small change, but it shows that despite his acceptance of Nia’s fate, he’s still upset by it and he has every right to be. It makes the scene so much powerful because it conveys his resolve not to abuse his powers to resurrect dead people. It also shows just how much Simon has grown and matured over the course of the series by acknowledging his grief but still moving forward.
After the credits of The Lights in the Sky are Stars roll, it focuses more on Simon wandering around the world. He helps whoever he can and plants flowers in Nia’s memory, which she mentioned as a dream of hers in a new, earlier scene in the movie. He also wears Nia’s wedding ring as a necklace, which is such a small touch that I love. It shows that he always keeps her close to him, and I prefer him keeping the ring with him rather than having it as a place marker at her grave.
There are many other small changes that The Lights in the Sky are Stars makes that are good as well, but these are the most noteworthy because of what they add to the lore of the series and characters, specifically Simon and Nia. Wondering why Childhood’s End hasn’t been praised more? Well…
The starkly different animation style from Episode 4 of Gurren Lagann was not redone in Childhood’s End. I’m not sure if this radically different and unfitting style was maintained because of the guest director that worked on the original episode, and I suppose that if that’s the case I can’t argue with it too much even if it doesn’t make any sense in movie format and looks rather cheap. The bigger issue is that the budget was largely spent on adding pointless scenes of fan service. These scenes do nothing for the story and characters, and it’s frustrating to see new animation devoted to such irrelevant scenes in a series that already has an excess of just that.
The fact that Nia blurts out her identity as Lordgenome’s daughter as soon as she meets Team Dai Gurren in Childhood’s End eliminates all suspense about her identity. I understand that this was done for pacing purposes, and it’s not something entirely out of character for Nia to say, but it eliminates the build up about her identity that was done well in Gurren Lagann. This scene’s placement also results in several other scenes being out of order as well, and this leads to Childhood’s End feeling extremely rushed.
Many of the moments between Simon and Nia in the first half of Gurren Lagann are not only sweet to watch, but show a natural progression of how they fall in love with each other and eventually become engaged years later. Unfortunately, Childhood’s End cuts many of these moments from the film, leaving the audience wondering how they could develop such a close bond in only a couple of scenes. I can’t complain about this a ton since The Lights in the Sky are Stars makes up for this substantially, but it does make the relationship feel more empty in the first movie with so few scenes for them to interact to develop a genuine relationship with one another.
In Childhood’s End, Simon and Team Dai Gurren fight against the three remaining Generals of Lordgenome and Viral all at once. In the anime, these fights were broken up individually, so it makes sense for the movie to streamline these battles into one for pacing. But the individual fights gave a sense of scope and danger to the story and Team Dai Gurren’s mission, and defeating them all in this one battle takes away a lot of the tension that the show was so good at building up.
Childhood’s End concludes after the defeat of Lordgenome’s Generals, leaving the impending fight against Lordgenome as a cliffhanger. This cliffhanger isn’t very well done here because it’s needlessly splitting the story arc of the fight against the Beastmen into two movies. Furthermore, it leads to The Lights in the Sky are Stars having a jarring start continuing a battle that should have been resolved at the end of the first movie. Because The Lights in the Sky are Stars is forced to begin with this battle, much of the fight from the anime is cut down and feels hastily rushed and devoid of intensity, ultimately hampering what was a fantastic showdown in the anime.
In Gurren Lagann, the scene where the AntiSpiral is extracting Nia’s memories for analysis is already uncomfortable to watch. His apathetic attitude and monologue combined with her screams in the background makes the scene almost cringe worthy to watch, but at least it’s short lived and feels like it adds something to the story. In The Lights in the Sky are Stars, this scene is sexualized because of Nia’s nudity, and goes on for much longer to the point that it’s unacceptable. This may have been how the scene was intended to play out in the show, but it’s so uncomfortable to watch that it was reminding me of the offensive moments of Kill La Kill, and that’s not okay.
In Gurren Lagann, the final battle feels like it has real stakes largely due to how many characters sacrifice their lives for Team Dai Gurren’s victory. These deaths, while sad (especially in Kittan’s case), help the story have real stakes that it lacked to this point. By having these characters die, it gives a sense of urgency and shows that battles can’t be won without sacrifices. In Gurren Lagann, these sacrifices are handled well and add to the story and characters. In The Lights in the Sky are Stars however, all of these minor characters – except Kittan – survive. This is rather irksome because it takes away the meaning of their sacrifices in the show – by having them live through the final battle, it makes it feel too easily won.
So, are the movies worth watching? Well, yes and no. The pacing of Childhood’s End is very sporadic and there aren’t many good changes that enhance the story – with the exception of the fantastic introduction. This isn’t to say the first half of the show isn’t good, but there’s something about the pacing of those episodes in a show format that made them exciting to watch. But having the way these episodes are condensed in Childhood’s End, the movie feels rushed and lacks fluidity.
On the other hand, The Lights in the Sky are Stars is much better. The pacing is slower and more fluid, and the additional scenes (for the most part) add a lot to the lore and characters and story. Neither of the movies are without flaws however, and because of this I think that ultimately, the show tells the story best. The movies are overall a great addition for the series and retell the story in a new interesting way, but they shouldn’t replace the experience watching the show. Gurren Lagann’s story is told most strongly in an episodic progression because its tonal shifts are more exciting and dynamic. In some ways, the movies compliment the show well, but Gurren Lagann is an adored anime because of the risks it takes to develop its story and characters, and it’s a show that should be experienced by every anime fan.
I haven’t talked much about anime endings in this series of posts, but Erased’s is certainly a notable one. It takes a much more stylized direction with its art style and colors, weaving abstract images and scenes together to create the ending. Because of the unique art style and more abstract imagery, the ending doesn’t outright spoil anything in the show – certain thematic ideas are represented, but it’s only by watching the show that the images gain meaning. The song suits the mood of the show well, using a more somber yet hopeful tone.
With season 2 of Tales of Zestiria the X underway, it reminded me of how much I enjoy the opening of the first season. I’ve talked about another opening Flow has done before, and this song also proves to be just as great, with the bagpipes in the beginning and the combination of pop and rock during the chorus. The opening has gorgeous visuals that establishes the powers and abilities of the large cast of characters. In addition, the opening balances the action scenes with more calm ones that give a glimpse of the world and other characters that the main group will meet in their journey. I didn’t skip this opening very often when going through Tales of Zestiria the X, and anytime an opening has the staying power to be viewed constantly, I think that’s a good sign.
The opening of Trigun is pretty unique because of its lack of lyrics. Despite that, it’s an extremely catching and fun song to listen to. The opening itself features mostly establishing shots of the characters and the setting, although there are different versions of the opening that correspond to each episode by showing some footage from it. That could almost count as spoilers, but without context it can’t really spoil much, and if anything I found myself excited to meet the new characters and villains that Vash would have throughout the show.
Last summer I made a series of posts about my favorite anime openings and endings. Now the list continues in this series of winter edition posts!
Is it really a surprise that I’m talking about a song from the show I have an unhealthy obsession withYuri!!! On Ice? Not only is this show great, but so is the music. “History Maker” is an addictively catchy song. I immediately loved it when I first heard it, and the opening is so good that I have not once skipped it when watching Yuri!!! On Ice. The opening itself is fun to watch despite looping the same animation because of the color and background variations it has in each episode. “History Maker” beautifully blends orchestral melodies and modern pop with convincingly sung English lyrics to create a fantastic opening that never gets old to watch or listen to. The full version of the song is even better because of how the lyrics reflect the desires of the characters.
This semester of Anime Club introduced a bunch of new shows for me to watch, thanks to the strong selection of anime that were released in the Fall season. Dabbling in the new shows is fun, but it also gave me a chance to revisit some older anime series too, and even finish one that I’ve been meaning to watch for years now.
Tales of Zestiria the X (Season 1): 4.5/5 Tales of Zestiria the X features the gorgeous animation from the in-game cutscenes and the soundtrack from the game as well. The English dub is fantastic as well, with the actors from the game returning for their roles. The tie-in with Berseria is neat but tonally jarring in spots, not to mention that it doesn’t go anywhere story-wise. I hope the pay off will be smoothly incorporated into the next season, because the possibility that it was just a cheap plug for Berseria to get popular and have no narrative purpose is pretty lame and a missed opportunity. But besides that, Zestiria feels like a stand-alone anime, taking some creative liberties with the narrative and characters to add depth where the game may have lacked it. The action is fast-paced and exciting to watch, and as a nice touch, the previews for the next episodes resemble the skits from the game as the characters interact with each other.
Sweetness and Lightning: 3/5 Sweetness and Lightning gushes with cuteness and tugs at the heartstrings. The best part of the show is the relationship between Inuzuka and Tsumugi, though the rest of the cast isn’t bad. To be honest, I could have done without the huge emphasis on cooking with Kotori. I realize that’s what makes Tsumugi happy and that’s what her dad wants more than anything, but I think the show could have easily focused on their dynamic as father and daughter without that. The food looks great, and their reactions are pretty amusing, but the show sort of falls into a redundant formula that can make it difficult to stay invested in. All of the scenes with Inuzuka and Tsumugi working through their problems together are great, and it’s in those moments that I feel the show is at its strongest. Sadly, these scenes are too few and far in between, and the conclusion leaves a lot to be desired. Overall, as my first real slice of life anime, Sweetness and Lightning is by no means bad, but it could have been better.
I didn’t know what to expect from Trigun but it definitely defied my initial thoughts when I first saw the early episodes a few years back. The tone is pretty lighthearted and focused on developing the characters. Towards the latter half of the show though, the narrative takes precedence and becomes considerably darker, with heartbreaking character deaths and intense battles. The finale is absolutely incredible, with exciting action and epic character moments that add to the experience. There are some ambiguous aspects of Trigun that, while I want to know more about them, the fact that the show doesn’t delve into it adds mystery to the characters rather than hurting the story at any point.
Yuri!! On Ice: 5/5
I know I gave Yuri!!! On Ice a 4.5/5 on the ATB podcast, but that was before I got to the episodes that make this show truly stand out among its peers. Yuri!!! On Ice is a fantastic show. The music is excellent, the animation is gorgeous, and the characters are well-written and extremely relatable, and their problems are handled with maturity. The show participates in using certain tropes while also subverting them in so many ways, making it a progressive anime for Japan. Yuri and Victor’s relationship is extremely sweet and cute, and at no point does it suffer from plot contrivances or weak character dilemmas. The show also does a great job of exploring love and sexuality and femininity versus masculinity in a realistic way that doesn’t generalize or stereotype ethnicity or gender. The finale felt slightly rushed, but overall really quite satisfying and still fun to watch. I can’t wait for the second season of this show, I have no doubt that it will be as enjoyable and wonderful as the first one has been.